David begins experiencing cloudy memories of a long-lost life, a murderous existence before he moved to America, where an accident took his memory and his sight. Under the wing of Don Michele, he was a chosen son of the violent, Sicilian Cortello family a family he ultimately betrayed. Now fleeing his ruthless New York City mafiosa existence as part of the family overseen by the irrational and explosive Don Fredrico - his half-brother, unbeknownst to him - David embarks on a journey back to his Italian origins. En route on a train, he encounters a mysterious woman, as well as Father Leonard, who senses that they all have a connection and that David has a past that weighs heavily on his mind. But the priest has secrets of his own, having long-ago murdered the notorious Williams. As Don Federico also sets out for Sicily, each of their paths are destined to cross in bloody confrontation, an expiation of long-ago sins.